Few people can have been unaffected by the news of the psychiatrist turning on his patients in the military base in the US. It has wide implications and this is the best analysis I have read Click here for a direct link
This article follows the news of the major shooting in American largest military base by the army psychiatrist Dr Nidal Malik Hasan who was known to be a risk and held extreme religious views. It was political correctness which led to the risks being ignored in allowing him to work in US military base. Dr Nidal Malik Hasan was not able to treat his patients while keeping his own belief system intact.
Bright draws attention to the impact of underlying belief systems on the behaviour of doctors. Now Medical students are brought up to fear the General Medical Council and Trust managers instead of loving and enjoying life. They are growing up in a culture where reaching targets matters more than saving lives.
I was brought up in the days when the needs of the patient came first, regardless of any personal cost. The results were not always as good as you wanted but strong beliefs that you were doing the best you could for that patient generally saw you through.
Bright shows the serious consequences of conflicts in belief systems. We will never know exactly what triggered Nidal Malik Hasan's attack on those around him, what combination of racism, religion, war sentiment and distress led him to pull the trigger but it is time for each one of us to see where we stand. We cannot have one set of beliefs for our day job and another for our home life. The conflict is unsustainable and the results unpredictable
The medical history is the most important part of any medical consultation.
Taking a good medical history is key to being a good doctor, and the key to
a g...

4 comments:
It's said of criminals that "it takes one to know one". In my experience this can certainly be extended to the dubious profession of psychiatry. There are however many valuable people who are able to help those with emotional and mental problems who are not doctors or psychiatrists and have a balanced perspective on life.
Andy
I have little reason to be grateful to psychiatrists because I have never found them particularly helpful.
My reason for writing the book Mood Mapping, was is no small part because of how little help I had received from the medical profession in relation to my own mental health
Thanks Andy for your comments, and congratulations on your excellent website.
It be great to meet up and discuss how Chinese and Western medicine map together and to find a common understanding between the two approaches. If you see www.teachyourselfmedicine.blogspot.com - the latest post looks at this problem
Thanks again - love your website,
Liz
Liz, Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) has perhaps the best method of differentiating a condition through methods such as the "eight principles" which give a great insight into the cause and hence a treatment plan for a disease. I am sure that 'western' medicine could learn from this and incorporate this into better understanding the process of an illness and hence provide more effective treatment. How to make this happen? Lets meet up and talk about this.
Andy
yes! my email address is liz@lizmiller.co.uk - can we talk offline? this is tremendously exciting - I would love to learn the eight principles of Chinese Medicine and see how each of type of medicine makes it diagnosis and management
VBW
Liz
Post a Comment